Do you remember your first set of keys? Were you fortunate enough to have keys to your own car, or were “your” car keys really your parents’ keys for their “not so cool” car? Whichever was the case, your car keys represented a lot of things. Freedom. Mobility. The ability to “get away.” Car dealers understand these things, and they can use them to your disadvantage.
The longer a car dealer keeps you at the lot, the more likely it is that you are going to buy a car. You begin to feel committed to the salesperson. You feel like you have invested so much time in the buying process that you should complete it. These are valid feelings, but they do not help you make an intelligent, economic decision. Nevertheless, car dealers play into these feelings. If a car dealer cannot use more subtle ways of keeping you at the dealership until the deal is closed, they might “throw your keys on the roof.”
If you have driven to the dealer a vehicle that you might trade, a car dealer might ask for the keys to the vehicle. The salesperson will tell you that she needs to get an appraisal of your trade-in. She will then hand the keys off to an unknown employee, who in turn disappears. If it seems to the salesperson that negotiations are not going well, your keys will be magically “lost.” The car dealer has effectively thrown the keys on the roof, so that they cannot be found. There was a time when some dealers would literally throw the keys on the roof in order to “lose” them. Now, dealer employees might say to each other “put them on the roof” as a way to say, “Let’s play keep-away with the keys.” At this point, the dealer will pull out every sales technique in the book to sell you a car. You continually ask for your keys only to be told, “We are still looking for them.” You are stuck. Your car is at the dealer, and you have no way to leave.
How do you avoid this situation? Do not give your keys to anyone until you have a written deal, including terms for your trade-in. This might seem cumbersome, but you need to avoid allowing a dealer to control when you can leave. Otherwise, you might make a car-buying decision that you will later regret.
There was actually a case in the Dallas-Fort Worth area years ago in which a hearing impaired person was allegedly treated this way. Here is the Fort Worth Court of Appeals opinion (later reversed by the Texas Supreme Court) -
881_S_W_2D_843_1-23-10_1042